Welcome to the fourth online issue of Harbinger – we’re excited to share seven original contributions to the field of social ecology. This issue was not assembled around a particular theme or overarching concept, and each piece is intended to stand alone more than in conversation with the others. Nonetheless, perhaps unsurprisingly, several throughlines emerge across them.
One of these is utopia: imaginings of the good future that draw us towards it in the present. Critics of utopianism from the Marxist tradition have belittled efforts at “writing recipes for the kitchens of the future.” From a strictest materialist point of view, such a future is not and cannot be made by our ideas, only by the subterranean movement that flows through matter itself; changes in the former are merely the surface byproducts of the latter. We must disagree. Human beings remake their social reality on the basis of conscious thought, in ways that vary according to how we understand that reality. Any stakes attached to philosophical questions ultimately stem from a basic belief that has at bedrock utopian implications: that what and how we think today matters to the shape of the future. Each of the essays in this issue channels this belief in its own way, toward a particular set of conceptual interventions that, via the minds of readers, are to be their own small interventions in reality.

The image we chose for this Harbinger issue is a French collage of paintings from the 1890s entitled Les Utopies de la Navigation Aérienne au Siècle Dernier, or Utopian Flying Machines of the Previous Centuries. Its fanciful depictions of various imagined technologies of flight tug upon the speculative impulse, and connect us back to how those of the past imagined the future. Alongside these essays that follow, however, we found ourselves drawn most of all to a direct and abbreviated translation: Utopias of Navigation. Perhaps unlike the anonymous artist, we’ve read this phrase not as a question of how one might “navigate utopias,” but how today we might navigate by them. In other words, utopia is not the space we traverse with futuristic instruments—utopia is itself a navigational instrument that guides our journey to, if not a utopia, at least somewhere better.
The issue begins, then, with Fay Lyssa Fabry’s contribution Reviving, Using, and Thinking Utopian: A Recovery of Murray Bookchin’s Utopianism. Throughout his major works, lectures, and speeches, Bookchin identified as a utopian. While scholarship surrounding his work often describes him as such, it rarely examines the content of his project’s utopian dimension, or the ways Bookchin himself defined, developed, and deployed his utopianism. Fabry has written an important corrective against these oversights; she here offers a systematic overview of Bookchin’s writings on utopia, drawing out how he defined his utopianism, how his utopianism interrelates with various aspects of his project, and how a renewed interest in his utopianism might benefit the continued evolution of social ecology.
Robert Downes explores further philosophical questions related to social ecology with his submission Reason vs. Reverence: Unsettling Social Ecology’s Enlightenment Roots with Indigenous Cosmologies. This essay reconsiders Murray Bookchin’s philosophy of social ecology by placing its Enlightenment commitments to reason and secular humanism in conversation with Indigenous cosmologies, Indigenous political thought, and Traditional Ecological Knowledge. Through Native Hawaiian pono science, Potawatomi ecologist Robin Wall Kimmerer’s concept of a “democracy of species,” and Indigenous resistance to extractive cannabis production in northern California, it argues that reverence for the nonhuman and more-than-human worlds, along with place-based ways of knowing, being, inquiring, and relating, need not conflict with scientific inquiry or radical ecological politics. Downes argues that indigenizing social ecology can expand its theoretical horizons beyond Eurocentric assumptions of universality and offer a more pluralistic foundation for ecological justice, decolonization, the dissolution of hierarchy, and democratic social organization.
Liberatory Ecofeminism and the Ethics of Care by Nella Giatrakou & Stavros Karageorgakis examines how various depictions of nature by the dominant Western patriarchal ideology have historically served to exploit nature and women more effectively. The authors examine the ethics of care, and how it has been used by ecofeminists to forge a new relationship between humans and nature – paying particular attention to the emotional portrayal of both nature and women. They argue that the ethics of care in fact reproduces a problematic model of human-nature relations, one rooted in dominant patriarchal norms that ultimately traps women in roles assigned to them by men. A redefinition of this relationship, beyond rather than within gendered concepts and informed by social ecology, is needed for a revolutionary and liberatory ecofeminism.
Ben O’Heran walks us through challenging philosophical questions by way of a discussion of scientific current events. In Social Ecology’s Cyborg Dire Wolf Problem, he examines Colossal Biosciences, Inc.’s 2025 announcement that they had “de-extincted” the dire wolf, and the surrounding discourse of science journalists and other scientists embracing or challenging this claim. O’Heran explores this discourse’s philosophical baggage, particularly the “problematic dualisms”—native/invasive, natural/artificial, and pure/impure—that have shaped it. While he deploys the anti-dualistic philosophy of social ecology to better think through these problems, he ultimately concludes that dialectical naturalism lacks the conceptual tools to fully grasp the nature of these genetically engineered wolves, and directs us to put social ecology in conversation with Donna Haraway’s “nature-culture” concept to help us solve the puzzle they present.
Seeing the real chances of building an ecological economy is difficult when you are constrained by the self-evident facts of normal daily life in capitalistic society. But when that normalcy is broken, one’s perspective on the possibilities for combining a good life with a thriving ecology may suddenly widen. One such “abnormal” condition is being an activist. Ecological Economics through the Lens of Social Movements by Olli Tammilehto proposes that reflecting on our experiences in social movements can teach us much about how to create an ecological society.
At any moment nuclear war – accidental or intentional – could bring about the extinction of all life. Ember Reed’s text The Revolutionaries’ Dilemma: Transformative Politics in the Nuclear Age argues that this precarity justifies the urgent need for transformative politics towards a rational sociality that doesn’t constantly risk its own annihilation. Yet this same precarity might also undermine the possibility of such a transformation; any major political upheaval risks a breakdown in command and control, and by extension nuclear armageddon. This essay explores this “Revolutionaries’ Dilemma” within the context of social ecology and its particular political program for social revolution.
Lastly, Ethical Verification in Dialectical Naturalism by ISE board member and instructor Max Puchalsky seeks to identify and fill a gap in social ecology’s philosophical system of dialectical naturalism. While “DiaNat” as laid out by Bookchin grounds ethics in nature’s developmental tendencies—its nisus— it leaves the method of ethical verification undertheorized. How are we to know that the ethics we extract from natural history are rationally sound? Drawing on Hegel, Marx, and subsequent social ecology, this essay argues that while eductive reason discerns which potentialities are developmentally rational, verifying these discernments requires a social practice of judgmental rationality, via deliberation.
Some of these contributions, particularly the final one, will challenge readers, even those well-versed in the ideas of social ecology. All of them, we believe, have important things to say about how we think, and why it matters. We invite you to join us for discussions on these texts, and possibly to write your own responses—in shortform for the ISE blog, or in longform for future issues of Harbinger.
Upcoming Special Translation Issue
We’re thrilled to announce that our next issue of Harbinger will be a collaborative international translation project. In 2025, Paula Cossart and Sixtine Van Outryve d’Ydewalle co-edited a special issue of the peer-reviewed French journal Participations on the theme “Communalism as a Political Project.” This special issue examines the resurgence of communalism as a contemporary political project at the intersection of democratic theory, radical democracy, ecological thought, and social movements. Bringing together interdisciplinary contributions from scholars working in political theory, political sociology, and social movement studies, these seven articles explore communalism’s intellectual genealogy, relationship to other emancipatory traditions, and contemporary manifestations in political practices ranging from municipalist movements to Rojava. It is our hope that this special issue will help break down linguistic isolation by bringing discussions of Communalism currently taking place within the French and English-speaking worlds into conversation with each other, sharing insights and fostering greater international cooperation.
Call for Submissions
Been thinking about an idea related to social ecology? Fixated on a theoretical or political question broached by an ISE class? Buried deep in a rabbit hole of theory or history that intersects with social ecology? Then please consider writing something for Harbinger! We are now accepting submissions for a future issue, and are more than happy to help authors develop texts from ideas to publication. Send your pitch, fragment, review, or polished draft to us at harbinger@mail.mayfirst.org.